The Dragon sign, and the King comes up behind him with two knights on horseback. Pops manages to avoid them until he hits a dead end at a Marvolo vs. Muscle Man and Five tell Pops to end this, and suddenly the commoners come out of nowhere and try to capture Pops. Pops is annoyed and states that he is not Marvolo asks why everyone calls him that, and also points out he just wants to go home.
He asks if they are stuck in this time like he is, and Muscle Man answers by saying that they go by their medieval names, then Fives adds that he has to put an end to the King's reign of terror. When they leave, they finally decide they will wear the costumes, and then Pops comes running up. Meanwhile, Muscle Man and Fives have been sent to the stocks, probably for refusing to participate, and they are clearly speaking out of character, to the annoyance of the commoners, who have thrown tomatoes at them. They beg forgiveness, and the King shrugs it off, saying he much fetch Marvolo himself. The King starts to panic and then calls down to them, telling them to pay no attention, and rains down coins on the two commoners and they chant, "Huzzah!" After that, he turns on the duo and demands to know what he said about breaking character. The woman says her ears hurt from hearing that, and the boy with he says that perhaps a refund is in order. Kind Edmond dons this unacceptable, to which Rignatius responds, "What the heck, man?! Pops is the one flipping out!" quite loudly, and two of the commoners overhear. Mordicus tells him that Pops got frightened and ran away, and that he seems a little confused. Sure enough, the King is angry, wondering what they meant by they lost Pops (saying it medievally, of course) while being fed grapes by Starla. Pops gets even more worried, leading to Mordicus punching Rignatius, telling Pops to come with them so they can explain everything or they will anger King Edmund, which causes Pops to run away and Mordicus to point out that the king will not like this. Rignatius then adds that the Mordecai and Rigby he knows "haven't been born yet", with more winking. Pops responds by saying he won't fight it and calls them Mordecai and Rigby, to which Mordecai says that unless he wants to be sacked, he should call them Mordicus and Rignatius. Rignatius them comes up to him and tells him what he is required to do: slay the dragon or everyone will want a refund. Pops is taken aback, saying that he is Pops and not Marvolo, but Mordicus insists on it with a wink, which Pops misinterprets by asking what is wrong with Mordecaus's eye. Rignatius says, "Oh, dude, Pops!" but Mordicus nudges him as to remind him of staying in character, so he calls him Marvolo instead. Pops approaches them and says he thought he would never see them again. Rignatius complains that his butt is itching and Mordicus tell him they have to stay in character, so he tries again, but in a medieval way. Pops keeps getting worried and then spots Mordicus and Rignatius up ahead. But everyone who passes by either ignores him, laughs at him, or calls him a freak. Meanwhile, Pops is sitting on a rock (with a sword in it) asking for help to get back to his own time. Rigby comments that he hopes the power will not go to Benson's head. Mordecai, Rigby and Skips wear their clothes but Muscle Man and Fives still refuse to wear theirs. He then orders everyone to find him and not to break character or they will be fired (or as he says, "smited with unemployment").
The Dragon, and if he doesn't show everyone will demand a refund. Benson grows frustrated and notes that he is the star of their closing performance, Marvolo vs. Benson obviously favors his costume (King Edmund), and then holds wizard robes, asking where Marvolo aka Pops is, to which Skips answers no one has seen him all morning. Mordecai and Rigby (Mordicus and Rignatius) don't seem to mind their costumes and neither does Skips (Barnaby the Ripped), but Muscle Man and High Five Ghost (Palom and Porom) do not like theirs at all. 30 minutes later, all the other workers are getting assigned their alternate personas by Benson. The Park is being prepared for a Ren fair - but Pops doesn't know this, and panics into everyone he runs into. Upon waking up, Pops walks outside his house and sees medieval props and people acting as if they were from that time. Pops thinks that he's a wizard trapped in medieval times, and he wants to go back home.